Your Ultimate Guide on How to Deal with Toxic Employees

Updated on 08/31/2023


Blog Image

Have you ever encountered employees whose negativity and disruptive actions undermine the team's spirit and productivity? Dealing with toxic employees is crucial to maintaining a healthy work environment. This guide is here to help you navigate through the complexities of managing such situations. We'll explore practical strategies, step-by-step approaches, and expert insights on how to deal with toxic employees. Let's dive into this ultimate guide to create a more positive and harmonious workplace for everyone.

What Is a Toxic Employee?

A toxic employee is one who in the work place exhibits harmful behavior in the work environment, team dynamics, and overall morale. Such behaviour goes beyond occasional conflicts or differences of opinion and consistently disrupts the smooth functioning of an organisation.

Signs of a Toxic Employee

Identifying toxic behaviour in employees is essential for maintaining a positive and productive work environment. Here are some common signs that may indicate a toxic employee:

1. Constant Negativity

Toxic employees tend to have a consistently negative attitude. They often focus on the downsides of situations and bring down the morale of those around them.

2. Gossip and Rumors

Engaging in gossip, spreading rumours, or participating in negative conversations about colleagues can indicate toxic behaviour.

3. Lack of Accountability

Toxic employees may avoid responsibility for their mistakes and instead shift blame onto others. They often fail to acknowledge their role in problems.

4. Disrespectful Behaviour

Treating colleagues disrespectfully, belittling their opinions, or interrupting them during discussions indicates toxic behaviour.

5. Manipulative Actions

Toxic individuals might manipulate situations to their advantage, creating division and confusion among team members.

6. Undermining Others

They may actively undermine the efforts of their colleagues, leading to a lack of trust and cooperation within the team.

7. Excessive Complaining

They may frequently complain without solutions, creating a negative atmosphere and draining team energy.

8. Resistance to Feedback

Toxic employees often resist constructive feedback and react defensively when their behaviour is brought to their attention.

9. Micromanagement

Controlling or micromanaging others, rather than trusting colleagues to complete their tasks, can indicate a toxic mindset.

10. Emotional Volatility

Frequent mood swings, outbursts of anger, or emotional instability can create an unpredictable and uncomfortable work environment.

Recognizing these signs early allows you to address the behaviour proactively and create strategies to mitigate its negative impact on the team and workplace.

The Negative Effects of Toxic Employees

Toxic employees can have far-reaching consequences that extend beyond their individual actions. The impact of their behaviour can significantly influence the overall health and productivity of the workplace.

Here are five detailed points that highlight the negative effects of toxic employees:

Hostile Work Environment: Toxic behaviour can cultivate an atmosphere of hostility, making employees feel uncomfortable, unsafe, and unmotivated. This environment hampers creativity and makes it difficult for employees to perform at their best.

Increased Stress Levels: Working alongside toxic colleagues can elevate stress levels among team members. Constant negativity, criticism, and conflict contribute to heightened stress, leading to burnout and potentially affecting employees' mental and physical well-being.

Diminished Employee Morale: Toxic behaviour erodes employee morale, as individuals become disheartened by the negative attitudes and interactions. Moreover, low morale can decrease job satisfaction and engagement, ultimately impacting overall job performance.

Reduced Collaboration: Collaboration is essential for innovation and problem-solving. Toxic employees, however, create an environment where colleagues are reluctant to share ideas or work together due to fear of criticism or backlash. This lack of collaboration can hinder the organisation's growth and progress.

Higher Turnover Rates: The presence of toxic employees can drive valuable team members to seek opportunities elsewhere. High turnover rates not only disrupt team stability but also result in increased recruitment and training costs for the organisation.

How to Deal with High-Performing Toxic Employees?

Dealing with toxic behaviours becomes even more complex when it's exhibited by employees who consistently deliver strong results. While their performance might be commendable, their toxic traits can harm the team and the organisation.

Here's how to deal with toxic employees in the workplace while maintaining a healthy work environment:

1. Recognize the Trade-Off

It's important to acknowledge that even though these employees might excel in their tasks, their toxic behaviour can undermine team cohesion and morale. Striking a balance between performance and interpersonal dynamics is crucial for long-term success.

2. Private Conversation

Initiate a private conversation with the high-performing toxic employee. Constructively address their behaviour, focusing on its impact on other colleagues and the work environment. Also, highlight that their performance is valued, but the toxic behaviour needs improvement.

3. Set Clear Expectations

Clearly communicate the organisation's values and expectations for behaviour. Reinforce that while performance matters, it should align with a positive and collaborative work culture. Furthermore, set specific goals for improvement in interpersonal skills and teamwork.

4. Offer Development Opportunities

Provide avenues for personal and professional growth. Offer coaching, training, or mentorship to help high-performing toxic employees enhance their interpersonal skills. This benefits them individually and contributes to the team's success.

5. Monitor Progress

Regularly assess the employee's progress in improving their behaviour. Keep an open line of communication and provide feedback on observed changes. This consistent monitoring reinforces the importance of sustained positive change.

6. Address Consequences

Clearly outline the consequences of not improving behaviour. If the toxic behaviour persists despite efforts to rectify it, be prepared to take appropriate action, including performance-related consequences.

7. Lead by Example

Demonstrate positive behaviour and effective communication as a leader. Showcase the desired standards of interaction and collaboration, setting an example for the entire team.

Also, if you want to learn how to become an effective leader, read our guide on mastering 8 leadership styles.

8. Prioritise Team Well-being

Dealing with high-performing toxic employees requires a delicate balance between recognizing their achievements and addressing their negative impact. Organisations can guide these individuals towards positive behaviour while safeguarding the team's overall well-being by fostering open communication, setting clear expectations, and providing growth opportunities.

How to Identify Toxic Workers Before Hiring Them?

Preventing the entry of toxic workers into your organisation is crucial for maintaining a positive and productive work environment. Here's a detailed guide on how to identify potential toxic employees during the hiring process:

1. Review Resumes and Cover Letters

Look for any indications of negative attitudes or patterns of conflict in their past experiences. Frequent job changes or gaps in employment might also be worth investigating further.

2. Conduct Thorough Interviews

Conduct interviews to gauge the candidate's qualifications, interpersonal skills, and attitude. Ask behavioural questions about how they handle conflicts, collaborate, and communicate.

3. Observe Non-Verbal Cues

Pay attention to their body language, tone of voice, and overall demeanour during the interview. A dismissive attitude, lack of respect for others, or defensive behaviour can be warning signs.

4. Assess Cultural Fit

Evaluate how well the candidate aligns with your organisation's values and culture. A misalignment could lead to clashes with colleagues and contribute to toxic behaviour.

5. Analyse Social Media Presence

Look at the candidate's social media profiles to see if they have a history of negative comments, conflicts, or disrespectful interactions.

6. Use Personality Assessments

Consider using validated personality assessments to provide insights into a candidate's tendencies and behaviour. However, these should be used as a complement to other methods, not as a sole determinant.

7. Pay Attention to Red Flags

Be cautious if the candidate speaks negatively about past employers, colleagues, or work experiences. This might indicate a pattern of toxic behaviour.

8. Involve Multiple Interviewers

Include different team members in the interview process to gather varied perspectives on the candidate's demeanour and compatibility with the team.

Also, if you want to ace an online interview professionally, read our guide on 14 Ways to Conduct the Best Video Interviews Without Any Hassle.

Note: Are you searching for your dream job? What if you could effortlessly explore various handpicked job opportunities from leading companies? Yulys, the best job search website makes it a reality by providing you with various job opportunities, including remote jobs with no experience required, Amazon remote jobs, part-time remote jobs, and much more! So, begin your professional journey today and find your perfect dream career.


We hope this guide on how to deal with toxic employees empowers you to create a healthier and more productive workplace for all. Remember, fostering a healthy work environment isn't just a goal; it's a commitment to cultivating a culture where each individual can flourish. Moreover, by taking proactive steps to manage toxicity, you're safeguarding your team's productivity and morale and cultivating a brighter, more harmonious professional landscape for all.


How To Deal With Toxic Employees As A Manager?

Address toxic behaviour privately, offer constructive feedback, set clear expectations, involve HR, prioritise team well-being, and consider consequences if necessary.

How To Deal With Toxic Employees At Work?

Handle toxic behaviour promptly, foster open communication, and support change while maintaining a positive and productive work environment.

Is Termination The Only Solution For Dealing With Toxic Employees?

While it might be a last resort, explore other measures like training, mentoring, or performance consequences before termination.

User Image
Aneeb Ahmad

Update at 08/31/2023

Aneeb is a full-stack SEO & Content Marketer. He drives our inbound marketing efforts on all touchpoints & writes just about everything related to career guidance, interviews, and professional growth. He loves talking about football when he’s not wordsmithing.

A trusted Platform for 8,000+ businesses around the world

Some of the most renowned businesses post jobs on Yulys to find the perfect talent. Be the next one and find the right fit for your organization.

Get the Latest Updates from
Yulys Resource Center